THEME STUDY
By Eva Chow
A recurring and important theme in the texts studied this year is overcoming adversity. The texts and film can be connected by the similarities they have through their portrayal of overcoming adversity. However, the adversities can also be contrasted. In Job by Dan Preston, adversity is shown when Job faces the challenge of escaping his abusive family; adversity for Job occurs regularly in his life. In The Blindside directed by John Lee Hancock, Michael’s adversity is escaping from Hurt Village, from which he is trapped. Michael can not escape from Hurt Village because he has no money and no one to help him. Looking for Alaska by John Green features adversity when Alaska blames herself for her mother’s death. It shows how Alaska is crushed by her adversity, and in turn self destructs. In the novel Tomorrow, When the War Began by John Marsden, a group of teenagers are faced with the adversity that they are too young to deal with. The war becomes a major part of their life and they face many adversities. Adversity is shown throughout the texts because it is something everyone encounters. Challenges are encountered by people on a daily basis. The adversities are similar in the texts studied this year are similar because the characters change due to the challenges they face.
The texts Job and the film The Blindside can be compared and contrasted by their portrayal of the theme overcoming adversity. The characters Job and Michael share similar adversities – the metaphorical prisons that they struggle to escape from. Job’s prison is his home because it is difficult for him to escape because he is still a child. Michael’s prison is Hurt Village and it was difficult for him to escape from it because he had no money and no place to go. Job by Dan Preston shows how adversity is difficult to overcome when it is a place. Job is verbally and probably physically abused by his mother and her boyfriend, which is a challenge he deals with daily. Job finds it difficult to escape from his prison because he is young and at that age, relies on his mother to provide for him. “It is hard to see how Job could have lived down there, with his mum and her man being the way they were, and not turned out like them.” This quote shows that despite Job enduring the terrible behavior he is forced to deal with, he goes down a different path. Because of his adversity , Job grows independent more quickly than a regular child of his age and his maturity grows too. If Job were to leave his home, he would have to be independent and self-reliant because there would be no one else to provide for him. A similar adversity to the one in that Job deals with is featured in the film The Blindside. Michael, an impoverished boy with no one to take care of him except for himself is trapped in Hurt Village. Michael grows independent within his prison because no one else will substantially look after him; his mother is a drug addict. This situation was similar to the one in Job because Job too grows independent because his mother is not a good one and she is a drug dealer. Job and Michael were trapped in prisons that were created from poor living standards and dysfunctional families. The characters Job and Michael show that when overcoming an adversity, you can change as a person. Job is selfless and protects the defenseless; Job hits an older playground bully. “Everytime there was trouble at school, Job took the blame.” Job also takes the blame when the people around him get in trouble. He takes the blame himself rather than watch others get in trouble. Michael is gentle, caring and protective. “He scored a 98 percentile in one category.” This quote refers to the tests that Michael did, and he scored a 98 in protective instincts. His protectiveness shines through when in a car crash, blocks the full force of the air bag with his arm to protect SJ. Their similar adversities has made both characters develop selfless personalities. However, Job and The Blindside are different from each other too because of the way the characters Job and Michael escape from their adversities. Job willingly leaves his home after he purposefully sets off an explosion. He leaves incriminating information for the police to arrest his mother and her boyfriend. Michael leaves because Steve takes him. Michael is unaware of the place he is going. Job has a plan for when he leaves and is ready (the briefcase of money). However, when Michael leaves Hurt Village he is further bombarded by adversities. This shows that Michael is willing to go with wherever without a plan, as long as he can escape Hurt Village. However, Job is willing to leave with a plan. This shows how adversity has affected the lives of both individuals; one willing to leave without a substantial plan and the other willing to go after plenty of preparation. Adversity in this form is important to learn about because it shows how challenges can make someone extremely desperate to leave a place; they are willing to go without a proper plan. Job and Michael changed due to their adversities. It is important to learn about adversity in this way because people can change or be significantly affected by the challenges they encounter daily. Challenges are something everyone deals with and can change someone for the better.
The Blindside is similar to Looking for Alaska because the main characters, Michael and Alaska, had mother’s that greatly impacted the outcome of their lives. Their adversities were their mother’s. The way they deal with this adversity is very different, and also the outcome in The Blindside is different to that in Looking for Alaska. Michael’s mother was a drug addict and she was not capable of raising Michael in her condition. Due to this, Michael grew up without a motherly figure and had to fiend for himself. Michael becomes self-reliant without his mother because there is no one else that will look after him. Michael has to be self-reliant; he is forced to be because there is no one else. An adversity similar to Michael’s is when Alaska deals with the death of her mother. When she was younger, Alaska failed to call the ambulance when her mom was suffering from an aneurysm; as a result her mother dies. Alaska blames herself for her mother’s death as she did not call the emergency services. Alaska became independent without her mother, as Michael did without his. Adversity in this context shows the viewer and reader that the absence of a parent figure can make one develop independence much faster. Michael learnt to take care of himself without his parents and lived without a home too. Alaska got into university without her mother or any parents. However, this film and novel are different because of the way the individuals (Michael and Alaska) deal with their adversity. Alaska folded into hers and self destructed. ”Forgetting her mother, failing her mother and her friends and herself–those are awful things, but she did not need to fold into herself and self-destruct.” This quote shows that Alaska did not need to give into the adversity that she dealt with. Michael did not let his adversity overcome him, instead he held on and looked after himself until he escaped from Hurt Village. “With her drug arrest record my guess would be she can’t even remember.” This shows how Michael’s mother was. Michael grew up with a parent that was a drug addict. This would be have extremely challenging for him when he was younger. “He concluded that the labyrinth was a person’s suffering and that we must find our way out.” This quote from Looking for Alaska shows the viewer and audience the difference of character between Michael and Alaska. Alaska self destructed despite that fact she had friends and people that loved her. Michael did not give in and he had no one to look after him. This quote shows that the challenges of life that we face (the labyrinth), we must find our way out. Alaska and Michael both had different ways of finding a way out of their adversities. This is important because there are often many methods to overcoming adversities. Some methods will have lasting effects, such as Alaska’s death. The mothers of Alaska and Michael significantly impacted the outcome of the two character’s life; and they were adversities that the characters had to overcome. Adversity in this form is important to learn about because it shows how a parent can have a significant impact on the outcome of their child’s life. Parents are suppose to raise their children; but without a parent they do not have a role model. They have to form their own path without a parent to guide them. Sometimes the path they form can be a self-destructive one.
Looking for Alaska by John Green is similar to Tomorrow, When the War Began by John Marsden. This is because the teenagers in both novels are hit with adult adversities during their teenage years. They are adult adversities for the characters because they are challenges they are not familiar with and have never dealt with before. The characters from both novels show that they were not ready to deal with anything like this. In Looking for Alaska, Pudge deals with the death of his love, Alaska. He blames himself for her death and he has never experienced or endured the loss of someone as close as Alaska was. For Pudge, this adversity is an adult one. He finds it difficult to deal with and at the early stages of his suffering; finds it unfair. The death hit Pudge very hard because he was in with Alaska. and because he blamed himself for her death, it hurt even more. “If only we could see the endless string of consequences that result from our smallest actions.” This quote shows that Pudge deeply regrets the death of Alaska and wishes he could take back everything that he did. Pudge was one of the last people to see Alaska. Pudge and The Colonel helped Alaska on her last night on Earth, and he blames himself for her death because he let her get into her car while drunk. In Tomorrow, When the War Began, the characters (Ellie, Corrie, Kevin, Homer, Lee, Chris, Robyn) were mere teenagers before the war hit them. Their worries were about who they liked or who was dating whom. This changed when the war started, and they had to adapt quickly to the adult adversity. They are forced to change from teenagers into adults very quickly, which is similar to Looking for Alaska. Pudge is forced to deal with Alaska’s death, just as the group in Tomorrow, When the War Began were forced to deal with the war. ”Those awful things are survivable, because we are as indestructible as we believe ourselves to be.” The reader learns that when forced with an adult adversity, teenagers are forced to grow up very quickly. The awful things that the quote refers to the loss of Alaska’s mother. They may cope or they may be crushed by challenge forced upon them. Looking for Alaska is different from Tomorrow, When the War Began because of the type of adversity. Pudge deals with the loss of one loved one, but in Tomorrow, When the War Began, the group deals with the uncertainty of their loved ones. They are uncertain of the states of their families and friends; whether they are dead or alive. Pudge is certain Alaska is dead, but his uncertainty is whether she committed suicide or not. This shows the reader that uncertainty can help someone keep going when they are dealing with an adversity, such as the group of teenagers did in Tomorrow, When the War Began. They do not know whether their loved ones are alive, but they choose to risk their lives for them anyway. In Looking for Alaska, it is certain that Alaska is dead. For a while, Pudge does not want to do anything because he is very sad about Alaska’s death. This difference of adversity shows the reader that when one is uncertain, they are more likely to keep going when faced with a challenge because the results they will receive are unknown. But it also shows that when someone is certain about something, they can give up completely as Pudge did when he found out that Alaska was dead. This shows change as a result of adversity because Pudge changed due to Alaska’s death. This shows the reader that some adversities change people more than other adversities – some challenges are harder than others. There are lasting impacts to some adversities and the reader learns this from the adversities shown in both texts.
Tomorrow, When the War Began is similar to Job because in both stories there is an explosion to help overcome their adversities. However, the outcomes of the explosions in the texts are different. In Tomorrow, When the War Began, the group set off an explosion to Wirrawee bridge to stop military convoy from going through. Their adversity is blowing up the bridge because they could potentially be caught and killed. They are also risking their own lives to blow it up. Blowing Wirrawee bridge will be a way to get back at the invading country. This is similar to the explosion in Job because Job sets an explosion to his house to overcome his adversity. Job’s adversity is being emotionally and physically abused in his home with his mother and her boyfriend. He carefully plans out what he is going to do prior to the explosion and what he will do after he escapes. Both explosions in Job and Tomorrow, When the War Began are methods of overcoming adversity. The outcomes of them overcoming their adversities are different. In Tomorrow, When the War Began, after the explosions they are still stuck in the war. Corrie is shot in the back and Kevin takes her to the hospital. The group suffers losses and their town is still not safe to return to. Though they overcame the adversity of blowing up the bridge, they face an even bigger adversity – the rest of the war. The explosions in both novels significantly impact the out come of the character’s lives because they are methods of overcoming adversity. However, in Job, after the explosion Job makes he is able to escape from his families home. Job overcoming his adversity shows change in character because he goes on to be happy with his life. He overcomes his adversity onto bigger and better things. Later on in the story the reader learns that Job made it to Australia and is supposedly living a very happy life. The major difference between the texts is that one has a happy ending and the other does not. Overcoming adversity in this context is important to learn about because it shows that sometimes people use harmful methods to help them overcome their adversity. This is show through the explosions in both texts. The explosions were potentially harmful and could have hurt people in the surrounding area; however, the characters were desperate to overcome their adversity.
The common theme in the texts and film studied this year is overcoming adversity. Michael deals with the challenges of escaping from Hurt Village and becoming self-reliant without his mother. This is adversity is similar to Alaska’s one of becoming independent without her mother. Another adversity in Looking for Alaska is when Pudge copes with the loss of Alaska. There are similarities between Pudge’s adversity to the one in Tomorrow, When the War Began because the group of teenagers are faced with war; which they are not ready to deal with. Job faces the adversity of escaping from his parents house. It becomes obvious that adversity is something that people deal with every day of their lives. Challenges are something that everyone deals with on a daily basis. One of the most important things that the reader learns from the examples of adversities studied in these texts/film is that it changes people. Adversity can have massive impacts on one’s life and as a result, they change as a person. Lives and personalities can be changed as a result of adversity.